My review of Apple MacBook Pro 15-inch with Retina display (late 2013 model ME294LL/A, Intel Haswell processor)

Yesterday, I finally decided to take the plunge and replace my old laptop, a 13-inch MacBook Aluminum (late 2008 model).  With TWO battery replacements, TWO memory upgrades, and TWO storage upgrades, I feel that it has served me extremely well for the last 5 years.  But even with 8GB RAM and 120GB SSD today, it still felt sluggish, and its battery was showing its age.  With new MacBooks out having much longer battery life, it was finally time for a new MacBook!

Brand new!

As a side note, my old MacBook experienced a very unfortunate fall early this year (Thomas!!).  But even with a pretty significant dent on one corner, its display held together, and it continues to hum along today.  My wife's MacBook also suffered a similar fate recently (again, Thomas!!), and it also continues to work without issues.  I think it is a great testament to MacBook's quality and engineering, and I didn't hesitate to buy another.

Specification

After much consideration, I decided to pick up a MacBook Pro with the following spec (ME294LL/A):

  • 2.3 GHz quad-core Intel Core i7-4850HQ processor (Turbo Boost up to 3.5 GHz) with 6 MB shared L3 cache.
    • Geekbench score: 11956 (vs. my old MacBook at 2036!)
  • 15.4-inch, LED backlit IPS panel with 2880 by 1800 resolution (Retina display)
  • 512 GB Solid State Drive
  • 16 GB of 1600 MHz DDR3L onboard memory
  • 8 hour battery
  • Intel Iris Pro Graphics, plus NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M with 2 GB of GDDR5 memory and automatic graphics switching
  • Two Thunderbolt 2 ports, Two USB 3.0 ports, One HDMI port, One SDXC card slot
  • 802.11ac Wi‑Fi wireless networking
  • Bluetooth 4.0
  • Weight: 4.46 pounds (2.02 kg)

Significant New Features

There are a number of significant upgrades in my new MacBook Pro that are worthy of some description:

1. Battery Life!

One of the primary reason I have been holding out for a new laptop was that I wanted a real boost in the battery life.  For those who aren't aware, Intel recently released the Haswell family of Core i3/i5/i7 processors, which are SIGNIFICANTLY more power efficient than its predecessors.  The CPU used in this particular MacBook is the Intel Core i7-4850HQ Processor with 4 cores and Hyper-threading enabled.  While Apple claims "8 Hours of web browsing", my experience so far exceeds that figure.

While I haven't executed an exhaustive battery test on my new MacBook Pro, I am going to guess that I will be able to get ~10 hours of use reliably.  There were reports of 9+ hours of use from a similarly equipped Ivy Bridge MacBook Pro, when Apple claimed only 7 hours.  Stay tuned for more updates in near future.

2. Insanely Fast Storage!

Current generation of SATA 3.0 (6 Gbps) MLC Solid State Drives (SSDs) usually top out around ~550 MB/sec.  But when hooked up via PCI-Express bus instead, those SSDs can perform at significantly higher level.  Apple did the right thing with the new MacBook Pro (and Air) and decided to use the PCIe SSD interface instead, and the result is quite awesome!  Blackmagic Disk Speed Test reports Read: 729.6 MB/sec, and Write: 709.2 MB/sec!!

With that much of storage bandwidth, and not-surprisingly, EVERYTHING I do on my new MacBook Pro seems "instantaneous".  Everything loads so quickly and effortlessly, I feel I am able to get a lot more stuff done.

Performance

  • Windows Experience Index score, on Boot Camp Win 7 64-bit
    • Processor: 7.7
    • Memory: 7.9
    • Graphics: 7.2
    • Gaming graphics: 7.2
    • Primary hard disk: 7.9
  • Tomb Raider (2013) benchmark, on Boot Camp Win 7 64-bit
    • All with Motion Blur and Screen Effects ON; made no discernible difference when turned OFF.
    • At 2880 by 1800 
      • Ultimate - Min: 4.5 fps, Max: 8.4 fps, Ave: 6.1 fps
      • High - Min: 12.5 fps, Max: 19.6 fps, Ave: 16.4 fps
      • Normal - Min: 15.6 fps, Max: 23.3 fps, Ave: 19.4 fps
      • Low - Min: 19.6 fps, Max: 30.2 fps, Ave: 23.8 fps
    • At 1920 by 1080 
      • Ultimate - Min: 8.9 fps, Max: 16.5 fps, Ave: 12.2 fps
      • High - Min: 27.2 fps, Max: 42.8 fps, Ave: 34.7 fps
      • Normal - Min: 31.1 fps, Max: 48.6 fps, Ave: 41.6 fps
      • Low - Min: 30.0 fps, Max: 62.1 fps, Ave: 52.6 fps
    • At 1280 by 720
      • Ultimate - Min: 13.2 fps, Max: 30.0 fps, Ave: 19.4 fps
      • High - Min: 40.9 fps, Max: 62.1 fps, Ave: 53.3 fps
      • Normal - Min: 41.5 fps, Max: 62.0 fps, Ave: 59.4 fps
      • Low - Min: 56.3 fps, Max: 62.3 fps, Ave: 59.9 fps

Conclusion

Overall I am completely blown away by my new MacBook Pro, especially when compared to my old MacBook.  It is completely worth it!  I am very impressed with its new Intel Haswell CPU, as well as its NVIDIA GT 750M GPU performance for occasional gaming.

Next week, I will update and share my experience on other aspects of my new MacBook Pro - please let me know if you have any questions or areas that you want me to write up on.  Thanks.

Roy


Disclosure: While I am not paid by anyone to write this review, I may be compensated if you purchase products through links on my blog.

14 comments:

  1. Hello and Thank you Mr. Roy for taking the time to give your readers this review on the new MacBook Pro 15" with Retina display.

    My question to you is - I have read from other post that the Retina is not good for Windows software. Have you been able to test that as yet?

    Not everyone is willing to spend that kind of money when (if needed to) he/she can get a PC with better or similar specs for less.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was able to do an install of Windows 8.1 Pro via Boot Camp today, and I spend some time setting up that environment.

    One downside that I see on Windows 8.1 is the battery life; it basically reports 4+ hours on a full charge, and I don't think it's reporting it incorrectly. What's interesting is that I can only see the Nvidia GT 950M display adapter, and it won't let me install the driver for Intel Iris Pro 5200. So, I'm guessing that the shorter battery life is due to using GT 950M at all times, unable to switch to Iris Pro. I am hoping we'll see more support on this from Apple near future.

    In terms of "value", yes $2800 is not a small sum, and I'm sure a comparable PC will be available within a year. Personally, I wanted to get something that had long battery life NOW, and one that had enough power to last next 4-5 years. This is a really well made computer, and plus I would be supporting a local American company here in Silicon Valley. I have no buyer's remorse. :)

    My non-MacBook choice would have been a Lenovo Yoga 2 Pro, however that's more comparable to a MacBook Air. With this MacBook Pro, I feel that it can almost replace my desktop and that's a lot of value to me. Let me know if you have more questions.

    Roy

    ReplyDelete
  3. Roy,

    Are you able to switch between the iris and Nvidia under windows 7?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Thomas. No, so far I am not even able to SEE Iris Pro as a device under Boot Camp, and I am not able to install Intel's driver. I have also tried Windows 8.1 and the result is same. I believe that is what's causing the battery life to be much shorter under Windows (i.e. full-time GT 950M)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi roy thank you for review
    Ive just ordered the same mac. But ive read reviews and comments on apple support forums of users complaining of freezing trackpad and pointers. The thread has over 900 posts (some same users) with same complaints
    Would like to know if youve had a similar problem and if you know of other satisfied customers of the new haswell mac pro

    Thank you

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Tino. That's the first time I'm hearing about the issue; personally I have not had any issue so far, not even having to reboot once due to crash, etc.

    I also see that people report having same issue in Windows 8.1; I also have Windows 8.1 running under Boot Camp (install was tricky; had to install Win 7 then upgrade from there to 8, then 8.1), again no issues whatsoever, even under high loads playing games.

    Good luck with your new machine, although I suspect most units out there won't have issues.

    Roy

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5481839?start=0&tstart=0

    Heres the massive thread of complaints... however seems a 13 mbp problem..

    Fingers crossed :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi,

    Quick one for you - does it have built in WiDi (wireless display) functionality? I'm not Mac users but thinking about getting one :)

    Regards,
    Kon

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hiya, really love your review and your enthusiasm! On par with anything those 'professional' review sites can come up with, thanks for doing this, Roy!

    I was wondering how loud the machine is when idle and how quickly and loudly the fans spin when under load? How does it compare with your previous macbook?

    Your comments on this would be greatly appreciated, as one thing I hate is the sound of fans whining whilst trying to surf the net, do some work or watch a movie. Whilst gaming, I understand the strain will result in increased fan noise, but i'd be interested to hear your comments about how it fares noise-wise in each of those categories (idle, surfing, spreadsheet/word processor, movie, gaming).

    Thanks once again!
    Dan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dan. From what I can tell, the noise levels are...

      Idle: none; no fan
      Surving: none, no fan
      Working: none, no fan
      Movie: none, no fan
      Gaming: any fan noise is masked by the game music/sound

      Of course, you may have a much better ears than I. :)

      Delete
  10. Hi Roy,

    Thanks for the review on your new 15" MBP. I'm a 20+ yr mac user, but because of business have had to also work with Windows. I currently have a mid 2010 13" MBP, running Parallels Desktop and WIN7Pro. I'm not getting the performance I want from this config, and don't like using BootCamp, as I use the Mac side for the majority of my business use and only run some specific business Windows programs. Have you tried by chance Parallels with your MBP?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Bob,

    For non-gaming that I require Windows access, I use Remote Desktop to connect to Windows machines. For example, I have a Windows virtual machine running on another computer at home, that I have Quicken installed on; I simply RDP into that machine whenever I need to. With the recent update of OS X Remote Desktop client supporting RemoteFX protocol, it's very fast.

    I used Parallels awhile back on my old MacBook (version 5), and I felt that it was really too slow, in general, on the Core 2 Duo CPU. With my new MacBook Pro, I'm sure it's vastly faster, however I would still avoid using Parallels or VMware altogether. I personally have (too) many spare computers at home, and I use them via RDP/VNC/SSH. Given how cheap PCs are, you might as well setup a box and remote into it instead, keep your Mac free of VMs.

    Roy

    ReplyDelete